Since last week, the first class graduate comments ; courseware mm including three review articles, and related issues I design and guide the students discussed. The results, first article mm Beiqing Bao editorial classroom discussion time, I had to quickly come to a halt. the other articles and leave the matter under the class, thinking.
more abstract topics of some of the general reader may not care. but its more typical method of thinking and reasoning, writing is mature, professional, worth studying journalism students try to figure out the value of comments.
I made for this article The question is:
news and information in this comment what?
the news and information for understanding and discussing the whole chapter is what role?
in the work of the judicial system and political reform What is the logic?
respectively, of the judicial system of political reform and how to make judgments? to determine the relationship between the two, what is?
whole article thinking what is the logic of clues?
Do you have a basis to explain how the clues?
this kind of thinking leads a typical?
better to answer the first two questions. news is: the Political Bureau by the passed, issued execution. The first section of narrative also outlines the background of this simple message a bit. and this news and information in the article, the role of some students to answer the basic good: that pretext.
why is this pretext it? Obviously, we all recognized: This editorial is not a topic of discussion of judicial reform, but the topic of discussion of political reform. or that the first three paragraphs of its progress in judicial reform and the judge made a statement after the transfer since from the fourth paragraph political reform topics. So, the first three paragraphs can be seen as to my third question: In this review, judicial reform and political reform what is the logic?
I want to ask the question is: how from the judicial reform of the political reform about? so Where is reasonable to write? further, to determine how the judicial reform to support for political reform to judge?
That depends on political reform, judicial reform and the logical relationship between these two concepts, the.
is this problem, the classroom controversial.
aside and talk about this controversy. For the writing of this editorial intentions and arguments, the students are not controversial: This editorial is on the political system (the process) to make an active judge, and enhance the confidence of the people for political reform, reducing it for many years for the slow progress of political reform anxiety mm This is the topic and intent of this editorial, social and psychological background, which is why this editorial, we must do justice Reform of the message write the real cause of political reform topics. The social and psychological background, not explicitly reflected in the text, to be analyzed in the text outside the grasp. Therefore, this editorial is a persuasive writing ( Persuasive Writing), which is one of the most important editorial function. As for the persuasive effect, but also difficult to determine, with the argument of this article has some relationship, but not entirely relevant. because different recipients, there will be different persuasive effect.
controversial to say: In this article, the judicial system (and the article referred to the administrative reform, economic reform) and the political system What is the relationship between the in the end? This rational approach to this The core is fluent.
for the logical relationship between concepts, a clear response to the article, in the fifth paragraph:
political reform is not a vague concept, but the ruling party's governing structure includes reform, reform of state leadership system, people's congress system reform, administrative reform, judicial reform, financial reform, the relationship between central and local adjustment and straighten out the contents of such specific and rich.
to look at this overview and the judicial system and political reform is into a create the conditions for political reform. He also has a metaphor that When some students mentioned different views along this analogy, I discourage the further extension of this analogy).
students also made, according to the previous definition, judicial, administrative reform itself is a political reform (part of ), then, later referred to as replacement political reform and political reform Reform of the .
political reform since the Rationale: This is the author's own understanding of what is still the basis of the authority? If there authority for, say, the Party Central Committee document, then the full self to be established. If not, then the rational approach to the article is doubtful.
I think , This is indeed a key question. because it reflects the understanding of this relationship, common sense has not yet become universal. but here, it had to in the editorial position of the cornerstone arguments mm premise of deductive argument. This The editorial does so to some extent dependent on the two core concepts of the logical relationship between the. And at this point, the students and I are obviously ill-prepared. that is only enough to doubt, not to judge.
, however, I have always taken on the narrow boundaries of the concept of understanding, rather than taking a broad understanding of fear is to blur the boundaries of things, and thus lose the grasp of the nature of things. such as The value of the basic rights and fundamental problems, is more universal; and the Chief mm which corresponds to the English administration, involving the government's efficiency, rationality, but also more specialized and technical. For example, you say, the CD and the State Council department, the Department of commuted by the Twenty Ten departments, I think that is the administrative reform, rather than political reform. Provinces and Counties, or the city (prefecture) and Counties, I believe that the administrative problems rather than political issues. And the governor, the mayor who is elected, how to choose, it is a political issue. political than administrative, but that does not mean that politics included administration. because they each have a specific law. For them the difference between hundred years ago, American political scientist Goodnow has a thin little book, The fabricating public opinion when the emperor.
This is gossip, I did not say in class.
two after the article, referring to the economic reform and ; and its meaning is also demonstrated political reform is underway, but this argument back to the reform and opening up at once. It's demonstrated effectiveness, I have some doubts, but I did not say.
economic reform, certainly not will be confusion, so much so that blurring the boundaries of political reform. as County Standing Committee set up by the citizens of the county and below county level direct election of deputies, In the steady, gradual in-depth
No comments:
Post a Comment